Global Haiku Tradition--Tan-Renga 2006
Groups of students selected a favorite capped verse and explained why that tan-renga was a favorite.
Favorite tan-renga have been born and are indicated by the authors bylines.
Here is a 3-D tan-renga based on Liz Ciaccio's haiku and various caps.
This was created with Dr. Michael Kolitsky's 3D Haiku Program:
http://www.nextgenemedia.com/
summer night Ashley Knevich holding her their light
|
toothpaste tube Sarah Corso roommates cause That inconsiderate
Sarah Corso & Adam Stefo Two week old toothpaste tube toothpaste tube his anger
toothpaste tube Toothpaste tube Sarah Corso& & Jamie Devitt day after Sarah Corso & Melanie McLay toothpaste tube Sarah Corso & Rachel Cook the sergeant tensing |
hopscotching in Liz Ciaccio Brian and I really liked this initial haiku because it really seemed like it was made to be capped in this sort of style. The initial image we got from the haiku was a rather generic image of an average kid at play. By adding the capping lines, the tan-renga gains much more personality and sense of direction. Some of our favorite capped versions of this haiku were: the quiet boy Liz Ciaccio & Rachel Cook hopscotching in Liz Ciaccio & Brian Rhode We found it ironic that these two caps seem to convey a very similar message. The boy seems very out of place in that hopscotch is usually associated with young girls. If boys are involved, its usually because a girl is involved too. In both of these cases, the boy seems to be alone and possibly misguided. These both present very interesting images. Rick & Brian R hopscotching in hopscotching in with only brothers poverty forgotten dusty photograph Liz Ciaccio & Faith Martin Braided pigtails only child April sun shimmering sun hopscotching in five minutes Liz Ciaccio & Traci Rapp |
mother collapses Corrine Cullina mother collapses drying her hands Corrine Cullina & Alisha Goebel We chose this Tan-Renga because of the great imagery and surprise. It begins with an everyday image: a mother in the kitchen, washing the dishes. The emotion behind the scene is nothing out of the ordinary; she is simply cleaning up after dinner. There is a knock at the door and she dries her hands to answer it, but while she is drying her hands she glances out the window and sees a man in uniform carrying a telegram. That is all she needs: she knows. She knows that her husband (or son) is not coming home again. She instantly collapses on the floor, unable to answer the door. The surprise image in the last line caught our attention because the first two lines set up the scene differently then we expected. This made us feel like we were actually there with mother in the kitchen, watching her dry her hands as she collapsed. We would be just as confused sitting with her in the kitchen as we were reading the tan-renga until we either answered the door or read the last line of the tan-renga. Faith J. Martin and Erin Wyant angry hes forced mother collapses Mother Collapses rain pouring outside Corrine Cullina & Pat Steadman We chose these because each one brought a totally different scene. When you first read the haiku without added lines, it really lead us to believe it was about the war and a mother receiving word that her son had died. But the difference that two lines can make is huge. There are several that still encompass the idea that the mother found her son died: we liked the one where it starts with the rain pouring outside and then she opens the door and the rain is pouring inside. That had great imagery. Ryne and Rachel mother collapses another mother collapses Corrine Cullina & Sarah Corso The other one that we really liked that depicted the loss of the son was the one where the second-born suddenly becomes the oldest with the deliverance of the telegram. We both agreed that it encompassed that horrible feeling of losing a loved one and it also brought forth the small things that can change; a second-born being the oldest child in the family now. Ryne and Rachel the morning after
|
listening to Alisha Goebel listening to Alisha Goebel & Melanie McLay My group enjoyed the overall effectiveness of the caps used in this tan-renga. First of all, the entire image of summer matches well with both the changing mood of our narrator as well as the sound of a harmonica. For some reason, the bluesy twang of a harmonica is a musical sound that elicits images of southern folk, swaying back and forth on rocking chairs on rustic wooden porches during hot summer sunsets. Music is a physical element that moves and breaths and changes, almost playing off of our current emotional state as a way of shaping our mood into a more agreeable one. The notes dance before us, tantalizing us, encouraging us to embrace happiness. We find that the concept of a delta summer is all encompassing of the aforementioned themes. The basic function of a season is to change. We seem to be in perpetual transition between seasons as our mood seems to constantly be changing as well. Mentioning the summer as a specific season is almost an allusion to the harmonica music and the flood of other images that come along with summer those summer images which help us strive for a brighter tomorrow. Jamie, Pat, Brian B. listening to unorthodox special music listening to sitting around listening to listening to Louisiana roots pissed off deep collapsing in bed sipping coffee listening to
|
starry night Brian Rohde starry night Beautiful starry night looking starry night cold winter evening starry night starry night Overlooking the city starry night starry night starry night starry night starry night starry night |
in the twilight Erin Wyant This tan-renga capped was our favorite because of all the different directions it went in. Some of the haiku that came out of it were happy, some were sad and depressing, and some could have gone either way. For example: hoping to numb Erin Wyant gives it a negative connotation. This person obviously is at a pretty rough time in their lives and is hoping to numb their pain away, walking home alone in the cold and snow. On the other hand, this haiku from the same tan-renga: in the twilight Erin Wyant & Liz Ciaccio has more of an open-ended interpretation possibility. This guy could have just dropped off her girlfriend, or a girl he was just on a date with at her house. They might have just had their first kiss, or it might be something like a goodbye kiss. Either way, you know the kiss has greatly affected him and that hes thinking about it so intently, that he barely notices that its cold and snowing. I think the way the original haiku in this tan-renga is able to be manipulated into emitting so many different emotions is what makes it superior. after the party This is our favorite haiku from this tan-renga because of the before and after elements it has. Before the haiku is taking place, there was a party with friends, but it is up to us to fill in all of the details of the party and what actually went on. Then after the haiku takes place and after his person had gotten home, its again up to our imagination to think of what hell do next. We dont really know if he had fun at the party and is walking home happily, or if something awful happened and thats why hes not walking home with any friends. Also, we like how the twilight and snowflakes can either be read to be on the friends at the party, or on the person as they walk home. Liz & Elizabeth after the party Erin Wyant & Brian Rohde sparkling champagne pretending Im brighter now in the twilight in the twilight hoping to numb Commotion of the party a Nativity steps silent in the twilight Erin Wyant & Sarah Corso in the twilight in the twilight bone-chilling- |
dead-end basketball hoop Liz Ciaccio dead-end basketball hoop dead-end basketball hoop We liked the feeling of family that this renku gave off. It reminded us of an all American down home family, but not in a corny way. The first half of the renku can be taken in many different ways, as was done by many other authors. Yet, the last two lines complete the thought and really convey the authors affection towards his or her father. Alisha & Corrine the crowd roars dead-end basketball hoop broken concrete |
at the party Pat Steadman in my dorm At the party at the party sitting At the party heaps of the only voices swirl hope for the first time stood up at the party
|
listening Natalie Perfetti This is my favorite tan-renga because it leaves so much room for interpretation. I saw a lot of variety in the caps that everyone wroteit was surprising to see how many different images could be conjured up from the same starting-off point. Here are some examples of caps for this tan-renga: listening Natalie Perfetti & Rachel Cook listening Natalie Perfetti & Liz Ciaccio listening Natalie Perfetti & Rachel Cook sirens shriek by Natalie Perfetti & Ryne Inman Each of these tan-renga conveys a different image, creates a different mood, and stirs up different senses. The first one, for example, is a very lonely momentsolemn and isolated. We feel the cold, we see the white snowflakes, and we smell (and taste) the warm coffee. In the next one, we hear the soft sizzle of boiling water, and mommas presence creates a feeling of companionship and protection. The third tan-renga also creates a safe atmosphere with the presence of a mother, but this time the image is alteredmother is rocking her baby. Finally, the last tan-renga completely disturbs the sense of winter calm with loud sirens (which imply tragedy). I think the reason this tan-renga works so well and in so many diverse ways is because of the suggestiveness of the three original lines. Snowfall is silence, so it technically produces no sound. The paradox of this suggestion, then, leaves room for varying interpretations: is the speaker listening to the complete silence? is the speaker suggesting a comparison between the falling snow and the sound of something just as soft and gentle? or is it supposed to create irony; someone is not hearing what is actually making noise around him, but instead focusing on the calm silence of the snowfall? Essentially, the reason this tan-renga is so great is because it is extremely thought-provoking. Melanie McLay the silence listening listening Listening Natalie Perfetti & Jamie Devitt Listening Natalie Perfetti & Jamie Devitt sirens shriek by quietly wintry night
|
mesmerizing flames Rachel Cook mesmerizing flames Mesmerizing flames last bonfire back and forth mesmerizing flames mesmerizing flames silent dance Avoiding the guilt rampant arson Rachel Cook & Melanie McLay Allison and I chose this as our favorite cap because the use of an arsonist is unexpected. It highlights the speaker’s inability to say anything to make this horrible situation right. Rampant implies that it is not just this house or a single meek operation. It is a bold statement and the fact that it put someone’s close family member in harms way shows the audacity and violence they possess. It puts this family into a fiery state of vulnerability. The fire has taken everything they owned and simple words to help the situation cannot even be found. The person had her power taken away in one swift action. —Traci Rapp, Allison Lingren in the brick fireplace the brilliant heat of the seeing the bruises |
early in May Sarah Corso early in May early in May my summer plans morning sunshine Early in May early in May sun shines after ten years more surprising |
saving the worm Alisha Goebel saving the worm saving the worm already freed saving the worm saving the worm cousin John Saving the worm six years old to her on a lukewarm day saving the worm late at night Alisha Goebel & Ryne Inman I drop chubby fingers saving the worm fishing trip |
a beautiful man Jamie Devitt a beautiful man Jamie Devitt & Adam Stefo Our group liked this capped Ten-Renga the best for reasons of imagery symbolism. To start off, there is a great sense of imagery in the is haiku that really allows one to visualize this being trapped in a web. The poem says that the man is being subjected to the web, which implies that the being is doing this by decision. The contrast of the beautiful man, a positive image against the sinister theme of the spider web is great. Similarly, the imagery produced ties in with the symbolism evident in this haiku. The man could be almost anything, human, animal, state of mind, they are all pretty much possible. If it is a man, then the theme is of one subjecting themselves to a spider web can be talking of someone subjecting themselves to the trappings of the world around them, the eaten wing would then symbolize him losing the ability to be free and make his own decisions. If it is an animal, or more specifically a bug, then the poem is more clear cut and it is a piece about a bug, which possibly looks as if its a man, or one whose struggle represents those of mankinds. Andrew Barnick, Natalie Perfetti & Sarah Corso A beautiful man a beautiful man a beautiful man |
the silent eve Traci Rapp the silent eve the silent eve Santa comes in the silent eve |
©
2006, Randy Brooks Millikin University • last updated:
April 6, 2006
All rights returned to authors upon publication.