Lost Beauty Haiku Matching Contest Favorites • Spring 2006
once striking, Adam Stefo |
beautiful wife |
rain drops Rick Bearce |
your sparkling eyes |
once striking, |
rain drops |
||
|
top quarter champion = rain drops |
|
|
top half champion = rain drops |
|||
bottom quarter champion = re-reading |
|||
re-reading |
fifty years later, |
||
front steps Brian Blankenship |
re-reading Stephanie Dietrich |
years later |
fifty years later, Corinne Cullina |
|
top half champion = rain drops |
|
|
grand champion = rain drops |
|||
bottom half champion = one |
|||
wrinkles— |
one Rachel Cook |
girl |
trying to find |
one |
trying to find |
||
|
top quarter champion = one |
|
|
bottom half champion = one |
|||
bottom quarter champion = the old woman |
|||
the old woman |
porcelain angels |
||
the old woman Pat Steadman |
I see my face |
porcelain angels |
packed away |
commentaries
re-reading |
Fifty years later, |
front steps |
re-reading |
This pair ended up in our matching contest sort of by accident: when we set up our eight pairs in the matching chart, we didn’t notice that these two might get matched up. When they did, it made for some good laughs. These two haiku unexpectedly play off of each other in a cause-effect relationship. After reading them side by side, I imagined that the favorite childhood book mentioned in the first haiku was The Frog Prince. Paired together, these two haiku take on a new meaning—a meaning that is comical but tragic all at once. Melanie |
Although this pair was in the first round of eliminations, I found it difficult to choose between these two haiku. Both haiku convey original ideas. “front steps” puts me back into the world of childhood, the world that exists below door knobs. It used something commonplace and stationery to measure the passing of years. In “re-reading” I like the idea of pressing dandelions rather than roses or corsages as true evidence of childhood. Although I think “front steps” is better written, it employs less imagery and detail. I still prefer “front steps” as my personal favorite, even though the group chose “re-reading.” Natalie |
||
rain drops |
your sparkling eyes |
one |
Wrinkles- |
When our group was discussing the haiku to pair up, these two made up one of the most unlikely (and one of the last) matches. On the surface they seem very different, but underneath I found a surprising connection – nature. The first is about false beauty being washed away by the power of nature: the real declaring its ultimate power over the fake. The second compares a person’s eyes to a part of nature: both are fading. I really liked the use of the natural element in these two, especially in the first, when it shows how nature triumphs… maybe that’s why it was ultimately our champion! Sarah Corso |
This pair of haiku is an interesting match. They show two contrasting views of wrinkles. The first haiku shows wrinkles in a negative light- even one wrinkle, no matter how small, is “too many” in the eyes of the author. The other haiku shows wrinkles as “lines of beauty,” not necessarily implying that wrinkles are physically beautiful but rather that they with age comes beauty of the soul. The wrinkles, therefore, show that the person has become older, wiser, and more beautiful inside if not out. They are two very different views of wrinkles. Personally, I prefer the first haiku because I feel it is the better written of the two. The last line of the second haiku is a bit confusing- what does it mean? I don’t understand what the author was trying to convey with this haiku, but it was not conveyed to me. The first haiku, on the other hand, is very short, sweet and to the point. It uses only necessary words to convey an image and a feeling without being too abrupt or incomplete. The first haiku is the better of the two. Faith |
||
|
|
© 2006,
Randy Brooks Millikin University
All rights returned to authors upon publication.