Sound Haiku Matching Contest • Spring 2006
the sky shifts |
this silence |
thick summer heat |
slowly I fall asleep Corinne Cullina |
the sky shifts |
slowly I fall asleep |
||
|
top quarter champion = slowly I fall asleep |
|
|
top half champion = dusk meadow |
|||
bottom quarter champion = dusk meadow |
|||
dusk meadow |
the silence |
||
dusk meadow orphan |
huddled in the tent |
shots echo |
the silence |
|
top half champion = dusk meadow |
|
|
grand champion = dusk meadow |
|||
bottom half champion = hungover |
|||
late August silence Melanie McLay |
blinding sunrays |
just as the lightning |
snatching me from sleep Stephanie Dietrich |
blinding sunrays |
snatching me from sleep |
||
|
top quarter champion = snatching me from sleep |
|
|
bottom half champion = hungover |
|||
bottom quarter champion = hungover |
|||
hungover |
only our voices touch |
||
hungover Liz Ciaccio |
glass shards cut |
only our voices touch Jamie Devitt |
pentatonic hums |
• • • commentaries • • •
late August silence |
blinding sunrays |
the sky shifts |
this silence |
I liked these haiku together because of the seasonal element they each provoked. In the first, the month of August is mentioned, which is the height of summer. In the second, the seasonal element is the ice cream and the sidewalk, along with the sunrays. The second is very detailed in terms of summer imagery. The sound elements of both haiku are unique. The first involves the sound the scissors make as they are being used; the silence mentioned in the first line allows the reader to imagine hearing only the scissors. The sounds of silence and scissors work together to create the sound element. In the second haiku, the ice cream is the obvious sound element. However, the other details imply sound. For example, the sidewalk mentioned provokes the sound of walking on a sidewalk. The sunrays reminds me of a pool area and I think of splashing sounds. Pat Steadman |
I really like the use of silence as a sound in both of these haiku. They both do a great job of depicting how much more powerful silence can be than sound in some cases. It's interesting that both of these haiku are not only about silence, but they are also very abstract. I'm not sure I even understand what the first one is about or is trying to say, but it's very artistic and, for some reason, quite haunting. The second haiku, I think, shows the moment after a gun has been fired and maybe even the ringing in the ears is part of the silence. Both are very good haiku, but I like the first one more because of the eery sense of not knowing what exactly is going on. Brian R. |
||
thick summer heat |
Slowly I fall asleep |
|
|
This pair was one of the first to catch my eye as being two similar haiku, not in form or even that much in content, but in a very distinct feeling. First of all, the convention of both the near-onomatopoeic word choices (I say near- because while whir and breathing aren’t real onomatopoeias, the wh and th syllables produce an almost airy, breathy sound that very much resembles the whir of a fan or the rhythmic pant of someone breathing). Also, these sounds are very similar in that they are common noises that everyone has heard at least once, and they are both white noises, in that although we hear them, consciously we don’t really perceive the sound. Because of this and my experiences with white noise (I can’t sleep without some kind of constant sound in the background – the box fan at home and the hum of the mini-refrigerator luckily works for me here at school) the haiku are given a very soothing feel, which compliments the imagery well – the cooling breeze of a fan on a hot summer day, and the calming intimacy of a nap in the arms of a loved one. Both were done well, but I can’t ignore the representation of the cadence of someone’s breathing being so soothing that it is referred to as a lullaby. Brian B |
|
||
|
|
© 2006,
Randy Brooks Millikin University
All rights returned to authors upon publication.