3 Matching Contest - Kuro Vs. Mido - Spring 2017 • Millikin University
Kuro Haiku
ER waiting room Yunek Moore |
the marks on your skin Emily Chudzik |
clinging to the smell Brittany Walsh |
a love note Paige Dorsel |
ER waiting room |
a love note |
||
|
ER waiting room top quarter champion |
|
|
TOP half Chamption my eyes are closed
|
|||
bottom quarter champion my eyes are closed |
|||
repot the same plant |
my eyes are closed |
||
the lonely leaf falls Nick Retherford |
repot the same plant Yunek Moore |
never whispering Kate Gebultowicz |
my eyes are closed Amanda Donohoe |
|
TOP half champion my eyes are closed
|
|
|
CHAMPION & Overall Mido vs. Kuro Champion! my eyes are closed
|
|||
smoke in the evening sky— BOTTOM half champion |
|||
holding the door Nick Retherford |
red rocks Olivia Gonzalez |
overflowing trash Andrea Burns |
smoke in the evening sky— Emily Chudzik |
holding the door |
smoke in the evening sky— |
||
|
smoke in the evening sky— top quarter champion |
|
|
BOTTOM half champion smoke in the evening sky—
|
|||
bottom quarter champion a dead man's |
|||
a lone crab |
a dead man's |
||
she stares through Samuel Miller |
a lone crab Jacob Melssen |
a dead man's Jordan Oelze |
two breaths Kala Keller |
© 2017, Randy Brooks Millikin University. All rights returned to authors upon publication.
Mido Haiku
grass inbetween their toes Yunek Moore |
i can hear Amanda Donohoe |
stepping out of Jordan Oelze |
swiftly brushing my face Kate Gebultowicz |
i can hear |
swiftly brushing my face |
||
|
i can hear top quarter champion |
|
|
TOP half Chamption re-lacing her rollerblades
|
|||
bottom quarter champion re-lacing her rollerblades |
|||
interested in what |
re-lacing her rollerblades |
||
interested in what Jacob Melssen |
tiny ants Chase Smith |
re-lacing her rollerblades Nicholas Kemp |
neon hairband Nicholas Kemp |
|
TOP half champion re-lacing her rollerblades
|
|
|
CHAMPION the rings on the tree
|
|||
the rings on the tree BOTTOM half champion |
|||
i can feel Andrea Burns |
the bird lands Paige Dorsel |
a duck begs Nick Retherford |
the gender is revealed Samuel Miller |
the bird lands |
the gender is revealed |
||
|
the gender is revealed top quarter champion |
|
|
BOTTOM half champion the rings on the tree
|
|||
bottom quarter champion the rings on the tree |
|||
why am i only |
the rings on the tree |
||
why am i only Emily Chudzik |
one tequila Kyle Kite |
the rings on the tree Brittany Walsh |
dance with my friends Olivia Gonzalez |
© 2017, Randy Brooks Millikin University. All rights returned to authors upon publication.
Kuro Haiku Responses
ER waiting room |
the marks on your skin |
clinging to the smell |
a love note |
I really liked how they both incorporated Kuros haiku ideas into them. They weren't overly depressing, but both were very deep and took thinking to get under a darker idea. Both showed the kind of memories that they had that would haunt them. Kuro said that everything dies eventually and I feel like the poems showed little to no emotion in them. They just showed the silence and deeper numb feelings they have. Nicholas |
This haiku pair I find interested in because they both make me think of what could have been. In the first, the author is not ready to let go of what he or she had. It brings empathy and sadness to the reader. Most people have probably struggled at some point in their lives with letting go of someone, so this haiku could potentially relate to a lot of people. The second haiku is a little more vague. It is hard to tell if the author wrote the letter, signed it, and purposefully left off the return address. The thought could then be there is no looking back. But, I think the author received the signed letter, but there is no return address. It is a missed opportunity, which still brings empathy from the reader. I think these two haiku, though different, fit well together. Nick R. |
||
the lonely leaf falls |
repot the same plant |
never whispering |
my eyes are closed |
I really like this pair of haiku because they are both about nature. I especially appreciate nature haiku. There's a lot of meaning to be found in nature, especially in that of plants. The first one speaks of a leaf falling from the tree, while the second haiku is broader and only speaks of a plant. Both haiku are very similar in that they both start off with a bit of hope. For example, in the first haiku it talks of repotting a plant. In the second haiku, they are speaking a lonely leaf falling, which may be seen as slightly sad, but it could've met up with another leave. But in the end, both haikus end with a dreary tone, and hopelessness. This portrays Kuro's approach to haiku writing very well. Paige |
|
|
|
holding the door |
red rocks |
overflowing trash |
smoke in the evening sky— |
|
|
This pair was my favorite from matching contest 3. I liked this pair the most for a couple of reasons, one being that each haiku shows the stereotypes for parents. The one about the mother talks about cleaning, the one about the father talks about him crying/showing emotion for the first time. I also liked them because in both haikus it seems as if someone has given up and is at their last string. The first one, the woman in the haiku is ready to leave because she's tired of cleaning up after someone who is not her child. In the second haiku, I imagine the dad just got some tragic news and something in his life has ended, either his job or a person he loves dearly. It's easy to pair these since they both have parents, but examining both on a deeper level is why they are my favorite. Dub I thought "smoke in the evening" was well written and the flow seemed really connect with the reader. It was deep but it was not personally relatable to me. I think that seeing a father cry is different and unexpected, and it was different to see a haiku written about a father crying which is emotional and it brings more meaning to the haiku. I just imagined the father crying while smoking a cigarette. I think that it might have been a divorce from his wife and I just imagine him smoking hence the smoke in the evening sky. This haiku was powerful and this was my favorite by far. Olivia Both of these haiku elicited responses from me immediately. They each set up unpleasant images: the overflowing trash and the smoke in the evening sky. It is easy to get a harsh feeling right away. The one about the dishes continues with unpleasant images, and it is definitely something that I can relate to. However, this haiku then uses the unpleasant images to come in and make a joke. The other haiku brings a more nostalgic image to mind. It may have still been unpleasant, but it is relatable as well. I vividly remember the first time that I saw my father cry, and it is still a moment that I analyze today. I think that both haiku were related in their unpleasant imagery, but they took different turns at the end. They even relate to mother and father. Mothers are always picking after the children, and it can be unpleasant. I like in the father haiku that the smoke is covering or masking the pretty evening sky. This could be the author having a cloudy image of their father because of his tears. The story could go many ways. Jordan |
|
she stares through |
a lone crab |
a dead man's |
two breaths |
|
|
I selected these two haiku because I think that they went well with each other. The theme of these two haiku is death. Although both revolve around death they don't display it in the same way. They don't have to use the words death to explain to the audience what has happened. Their words are very detailed and hit the audience with a moment that no one would like to experience. For example, the first haiku makes me think of someone walking into a room and a man on the recliner is dead. No one would like to walk into someone's home to find someone dead. It's just a moment that's not comfortable and sad. The second haiku revolves around an infant and the struggle of survival. I see a mother watching her baby being worked on by doctors because the baby can't breathe on its own. Both these haiku are moments that I would never want to experience and correlate to death; therefore, I believe that they fit very well together. Kate This is my favorite matched pair from the matching contest. I think they both really embodied Kuro's approach to writing haiku. The first one is one of my overall favorites. I think the last line is clever and unexpected. You can take one of two ways: either a ghost is in the recliner or the man's dead body is still in the chair, reclined from when he was still alive. It's eerie and well written. The second one is pretty dark and also unexpected. I imagine a newborn taking its first few breaths and then unfortunately perishing before life even begins. Emily Reading these two paired together made me think of my grandpa and dad. When my grandpa was still alive and I would go to his house he would always have his recliner chair that he sat in. It was always a game to see who could sit in papa's recliner the longest before we were kicked off. When my grandpa passed away it was a hard time for my family. The first time I saw my dad cry, I remember we were sitting in the kitchen and I knew that something had been going on with my grandpa but no one had told me anything yet. My dad got home and sat my brother and I down and said that he had pancreatic cancer and that my grandpa had asked that we don't see him. By this time he had whittled away to hardly anything and didn't want us to see him that way. My dad teared up as he told us and I will never forget that moment. Seeing your dad cry is something that you don't ever imagine because, for me at least, my dad is my rock. He isn't supposed to cry he is supposed to make me stop crying. Caitlyn |
Mido Haiku Responses
grass inbetween their toes |
i can hear |
stepping out of |
swiftly brushing my face |
interested in what |
tiny ants |
re-lacing her rollerblades |
neon hairband |
I really thought that these two were a good match. First of all, they're both about bugs which is kind of cool. They both give personality to the bugs, which I really liked. The butterfly is given a personality and a mind of its own, and I loved that the author was interested in its activity. The ants also have personality because maybe they're racing! or maybe they're just crawling. Who knows? It's still fun. Jake I like "interested in what" because it gave meaning and value to those butterflies we all have. I like the butterflies because like I said, we all have them, so it's extremely relatable. I've never thought about those butterflies, but I think they're kind of beautiful because we 100% know what's a good idea and what's not, so those butterflies especially know. But yeah, beautiful image and idea and situation. Andie
|
This was by far my favorite pair of haiku in the matching contest because to me they were two sides of the same coin. They each took the same basic subject, rollerblading, and wrote poems with two entirely different connotations. One is rough and bloody, while the other is bright and positive. I'm more attracted to the rough and bloody aesthetic but it's very intriguing to know that two people got the same idea in their heads and could create two different poems out of it, all without ever communicating or planning this. They both have good visuals and evoke strong emotions from those sensory details, making them an effective pair. Sam I really like the pairing of both these haiku because the common element of rollerblading tells two different stories. The first haiku is not very innocent, with the person having blood on their body. The way this haiku describes the individual, I get the idea that she is partaking in roller derby. This woman is one badass lady and I really like the character. On the other hand, the second haiku is very innocent and simple. I imagine a little girl roller skating while her parents sit on a bench nearby. She is just enjoying life and is very carefree during this moment. Brittany |
||
i can feel |
the bird lands |
a duck begs |
the gender is revealed |
|
|
I like this pair of haiku because of its use of animals in two very different ways. The first paints us a very peaceful and calm picture of sitting in the park on a calm day and feeding the ducks. You also get the image of the duck begging for food, maybe the sounds of it squawking. The second I appreciate because of its humor. It builds up a very monumental moment in being a parent, and then squashes it with something weird. I think the contrast between the two is very funny and I wish I would've thought about it first. Kyle K. |
|
why am i only |
one tequila |
the rings on the tree |
dance with my friends |