Tanka Matching Contest 3 - Harvest Moon
(select your favorite for each pair and write it in the box below
or above the pairs)
(then select favorites of those pairs, etc... until one is the top pick)
Tanka Writing Roundtable, Fall 2009 • Millikin University
moon hangs |
a mist of soft light glows |
weights tied |
she casually mentions |
|
|
||
|
top quarter champion |
|
|
top half champion |
|||
bottom quarter champion |
|||
|
|
||
harvest moonrise |
bathing |
this golden globe |
the autumn air |
|
top half champion
|
|
|
champion
|
|||
bottom half champion
|
|||
finding time |
tea ceremony |
rabbits |
through the branches |
|
|
||
|
top quarter champion |
|
|
bottom half champion |
|||
bottom quarter champion |
|||
|
|
||
give me |
silent |
willow weeps |
weeping willow tree |
harvest moonrise |
silent |
(Winner) moon hangs |
(2nd Place) silent |
While these two really don't have much in common, I do feel there is a duality of perspective here. It feels like the first tanka's speaker is trying to catch the attention of the second. The first is basically twisting in different positions. I imagine yoga, but overall, it's a "hey, look at me" sort of attitude when combined with the second (alone, I imagine for a portrait). The second tanka's narrator, however, is busy looking up at the stars and contemplating the mysteries of the universe. Nice juxtaposition really--the first is down to earth, the second is completely disconnected from this world. I like the bones rattling in comparison with the silence--it's so quiet that you can hear the creaking of bones. Aubrie While I love the word choice in the first tanka, the overall champion for me would probably be the second. It transcends reality and tackling with the mind-boggling concept of multiple infinities intrigues me. It also tackles a matter of perspective--how does the "I" understand infinity in comparison to the "you"? Very well done. Aubrie |
The really beautiful tanka are those that conjure up an image in my head right off the bat, and this one "moon hangs" certainly brought about some dramatic images: a tired birth in the moonlight, a sea of wheat rolling in the breeze, and a sullen father contemplating the meaning of it all. I can’t relate to this poem at all but it still speaks to me. It flows so well and it almost seems like it’s straight out of a J. R. R. Tolkien novel. Jackson What a wonderful question in "silent"! “Is your infinity larger than mine?” Despite the beauty of the poem there is still that lingering question, that lingering doubt that really makes the story of this tanka interesting and exciting. Everyone stargazes every once in a while, but how many of us really take a moment to contemplate infinity? Jackson |
||
a mist of soft light glows |
Weeping willow tree |
the autumn air |
give me |
Unfortunately, I did not get around to having my family or friends complete the kukai. However, I completed the kukai and found it difficult to choose. Brianna
|
It’s difficult to say what I liked so much about this poem "the autumn air." First of all, I liked the fact that the autumn air is not “more clear than summer air”, but is more clear than summer itself, or so the language of the poem suggests. This comparison of autumn to summer shows an affection for the season that I found delightful. I also love the flow of the poem; it feels very organic when I read it aloud, and the last line seems perfectly placed to be read after a breath, which has a nice symbolic flavor to it. Joe The warmth of this poem "give me" is delightful. The use of the phrase “forever and ever”, instead of simply “forever”, lends a nice emphasis to the poet’s feelings. I think the most interesting thing about this poem to me was the way that “summer nights” was inserted into what, otherwise, would have seemed like a single continuous thought. Nevertheless, the phrase seems neither out of place nor confusing. I’m not sure how the poet did this, but the overall effect is beautiful. I also find it interesting that the poem is a plea or prayer of sorts – the “other” has not yet given the poet his/her hand. Joe |
the autumn air |
silent |
|
|
I did this matching contest with my housemates. Now it was nice that my poem, the top poem (or I believe it is mine, but I do not remember precisely whether it is or not,) made it into the final round. The bottom poem was the winner, however. I do like that poem quite a bit. Although I often do not like the use of relationships in tanka (probably due to my bad luck with them,) I thought that it was well done. And so I concede the victory gladly. I guess I just think about weather more, and you know it's just small talk. Haha. Gordon |
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
© 2009,
Randy Brooks Millikin University
All rights returned to authors upon publication.