Haiku Matching Contest 3 - missing
Haiku Roundtable • Fall 2010
umarked tape Susie Wirthlin |
broken radio Nora Kocher |
i watch her check Kylie Cochran |
lazy sunday Susie Wirthlin |
umarked tape |
lazy sunday |
||
|
top quarter champion umarked tape |
|
|
top half champion cigarette still smoldering |
|||
bottom quarter champion cigarette still smoldering |
|||
cigarette still smoldering |
|
||
river of tears— Jordan Pennington |
cigarette still smoldering Hollie Logsdon |
in darkness Jade Anderson |
scarlet dress Grant Dartman |
|
top half champion cigarette still smoldering |
|
|
champion cigarette still smoldering |
|||
bottom half champion my new country home |
|||
my new country home Kylie Cochran |
in all directions Aubrie Cox |
home alone Tara Goheen |
lost in thoughts Becky Smith |
my new country home |
lost in thoughts |
||
top quarter champion my new country home |
|
||
bottom half champion my new country home |
|||
bottom quarter champion the first night |
|||
the first night |
pigtails bouncing |
||
the first night Kylie Cochran |
dandy lion fluff Michelle Dixson |
pigtails bouncing Michelle Dixson |
autumn colors Jade Anderson |
Double Matching Contest Grand Champion
|
first champion cigarette still smoldering
|
|
Grand champion string quartet
|
||
second champion string quartet
|
Double Matching Contest Grand Champion
string quartet Susie Wirthlin |
public library— Jordan Pennington |
digging a hamster’s grave Jackson Lewis |
A flick to the lady bug Colton Shaw |
string quartet |
digging a hamster’s grave |
||
|
top quarter champion string quartet |
|
|
top half champion string quartet |
|||
bottom quarter champion
|
|||
blood moon |
|
||
blood moon Aubrie Cox |
a dark cloak Joseph Sparks |
heart racing Grant Dartman |
h i s Nora Kocher |
|
top half champion string quartet |
|
|
champion string quartet |
|||
bottom half champion whited out city street |
|||
sunday morning Susie Wirthlin |
secret ballot: Kylie Cochran |
crowd in a football stadium Jackson Lewis |
Abe Lincoln statue— Jackson Lewis |
secret ballot: |
Abe Lincoln statue— |
||
top quarter champion secret ballot: |
|
||
bottom half champion whited out city street |
|||
bottom quarter champion whited out city street |
|||
whited out city street |
central park |
||
third shift; a train passes Alex Kitchens |
whited out city street Nora Kocher |
central park Susie Wirthlin |
shrouded moon Michelle Dixson |
© 2010,
Randy Brooks Millikin University
All rights returned to authors upon publication.
Haiku Matching Contest 3 - commentary
Haiku Roundtable • Fall 2010
umarked tape Susie Wirthlin |
broken radio Nora Kocher |
i watch her check Kylie Cochran |
lazy sunday Susie Wirthlin |
These two together are really good, because they can both be interpreted as forgetting something. Like with the first one, maybe whoever was supposed to text the girl accidentally forgot. Or not. Either way though, they are both sad. In the first one, the girl is looking forward to that certain text otherwise she wouldn't keep checking her phone. And in the second one, the person writing the poem is looking forward to their mom calling them, but that never happens either... Tara |
|||
umarked tape |
lazy sunday |
||
|
top quarter champion umarked tape |
|
|
top half champion cigarette still smoldering |
|||
bottom quarter champion cigarette still smoldering |
|||
river of tears— |
cigarette still smoldering |
indarkness |
cigarette still smoldering |
I really liked this pair because they both refer to the moments after a breakup. The first haiku is not as specific to a breakup, but It can be perceived in that way when compared to the second one. The feeling immediately after ending a relationship is hard to describe, but I think it is somewhat captured in both of these poems. It’s a feeling of confusion—suddenly you aren’t a half to a whole; you’re a half with no counterpart. Jade |
they both speak of a forbidden darkness, or something we can’t fully know of. Yes, the cigarette still smolders, but was the ex-lover smoking it, or was the person who was left smoking it? I trace his lips, but does he trace hers? Is he asleep, does he brush her away; there is so much mystery about the two of these that a English major can story him/herself to sleep with. Joseph |
||
river of tears— Jordan Pennington |
cigarette still smoldering Hollie Logsdon |
in darkness Jade Anderson |
scarlet dress Grant Dartman |
I love the picture that this haiku creates. I see a woman at her weeding crying into her husband's coat. On a sadder but just as equally powerful note, I see a woman whose husband was killed and now she is smelling his old coat just trying to get a scent of his. Grant |
This haiku is so sexy! The use of the word smoldering, the cigarette, the fact that it’s an ex “lover” makes it that way. So much can be gleamed from these few words. It seems like the affair (yes I’m calling it an affair) had to end, but it didn’t end the right way. They both still want each other, or at least one wants the other. That might be even better. Regardless, the poem is very well written. Jackson |
||
|
top half champion cigarette still smoldering |
|
|
champion cigarette still smoldering |
|||
bottom half champion my new country home |
|||
my new country home Kylie Cochran |
in all directions Aubrie Cox |
home alone Tara Goheen |
lost in thoughts Becky Smith |
I really enjoyed this haiku because I could relate very well to it. In fifth grade, my family moved two miles down the road to live on the lake with several farm fields behind us. The house fit my maturing family much better and provided new opportunities on bicycles, boats, and playing in the field. I could not think of much more I could ask for, and that same idea is captured well in this haiku. Tyler |
|||
my new country home |
lost in thoughts |
||
top quarter champion my new country home |
|
||
bottom half champion my new country home |
|||
bottom quarter champion the first night |
|||
the first night |
pigtails bouncing |
|
|
This pair shows the innocence and world view of childhood. In Michelle's haiku, there's the young girl skipping along, while in the other, there's the child's worldview of death. Yet, after a second look, I think of the phrase, "Don't step on the crack, or you'll break your mother's back." When paired with Ky's haiku, I feel a potential story building. Almost like the second haiku is the response to the first. The pair actually probably couldn't be more perfect. The language in both has a childlike voice: mommy, pigtails, bouncing. Aubrie |
|||
the first night Kylie Cochran |
dandy lion fluff Michelle Dixson |
pigtails bouncing Michelle Dixson |
autumn colors Jade Anderson |
Double Matching Contest Grand Champion
|
first champion cigarette still smoldering
|
|
Grand champion string quartet
|
||
second champion string quartet
|
Double Matching Contest Grand Champion
string quartet Susie Wirthlin |
public library— Jordan Pennington |
digging a hamster’s grave Jackson Lewis |
A flick to the lady bug Colton Shaw |
If just like the image I get from this poem: four musicians sitting in black chairs, snow landing lightly on their shoulders, and a big black top hat upside down on the ground, filling up with and surrounded by little flakes of pure white snow. It is a little barren and sad though. These four are playing and all they get for their hard work is snow. They aren’t even getting a hello or any type of human interaction. They are only given snow. Jackson |
|||
string quartet |
digging a hamster’s grave |
||
|
top quarter champion string quartet |
|
|
top half champion string quartet |
|||
bottom quarter champion
|
|||
blood moon |
|
||
blood moon Aubrie Cox |
a dark cloak Joseph Sparks |
heart racing Grant Dartman |
h i s Nora Kocher |
Both of these bring dark images to mind when they are read.They also both mention the word ‘blood” with in them, which shows a slight similarity. I just think they were both very dark and frightening. The first one is emotionally scary, the thought of the suicide being attempted many times, and the second one is more physically scary, imagining being so near to such a shady act. Hollie This pair really stuck out to me. I love the usage of “blood” in both haiku and how it takes on radically different meanings. In both, the blood image is used not as something gory and red but rather something dark and mysterious. The first haiku is just heartbreaking, but still garners mystery. Why does the brother attempt suicide so often? And the second haiku is extremely elusive. We get no personal information, just a dimly lit scene and the indication of illegal activity. I love both these haiku and think their pairing was extremely well done. Susie |
I love the imagery embedded into the formatting of the poem; I think it’s very clever, and perfectly suited for its topic. I like how we don’t know whether he’s glad or depressed by this reminder of what he isn’t—and what he hasn’t—anymore. Also, the fact that it’s his and not hers is especially compelling. Ky |
||
|
top half champion string quartet |
I liked that a pair came up by sheer random happenstance about snow, that had a sort of emptiness. The hat I imagine to be empty, filled with snow instead of money, and the street is empty because it just snowed. This emptiness doesn’t necessary make anyone sad, because the quartet has each other and the family has each other and the people at the Christmas dinner, but at that certain moment there’s just a little chilly aloneness. Jordan |
|
champion string quartet |
|||
bottom half champion whited out city street |
|||
sunday morning Susie Wirthlin |
secret ballot: Kylie Cochran |
crowd in a football stadium Jackson Lewis |
Abe Lincoln statue— Jackson Lewis |
secret ballot: |
Abe Lincoln statue— |
||
top quarter champion secret ballot: |
|
||
bottom half champion whited out city street |
|||
bottom quarter champion whited out city street |
|||
whited out city street |
central park |
||
third shift; a train passes Alex Kitchens |
whited out city street Nora Kocher |
central park Susie Wirthlin |
shrouded moon Michelle Dixson |
Sorry, once again I didn’t write down the author. I like this haiku because it puts these 2 very different people on the same level. It doesn’t matter that the runner is jogging and then probably going to his high paying job while the beggar has been in the park all night, begging for some money or food. Either way, they are both human and everyday, they see the same sunrise. Becky |
© 2010,
Randy Brooks Millikin University
All rights returned to authors upon publication.