Haiku to Edit 2 - Sabi Haiku
Roundtable Haiku--Haiku to Edit 2, Fall 2006
raking leaves raking leaves raking leaves This one is nice because it makes me wonder what the person is thinking about. I think it would be cool if the person were thinking about what happened to cause him to have to rake the leaves. Maybe they were already in a pile and his/her children decided to jump in and roll around. Now the mess has to be cleaned up again, but you just don't mind after seeing your kids do that. That's my interpretation at least. Nate a breeze filled with laughter
|
autumn memories summer memories I love this haiku simply because I can relate. At the conclusion of every summer, my friends and I get together at someone’s house and have a big bonfire to reminsice and enjoy the last glow of summer. However, if the word “autumn” were changed to “summer” the term “memories” would apply better. Goli memories dance memories among the flames |
|
Another day alone I could actually hear the pain inside the voice of the poet. The poem is brief and simple, yet is so heavy with emotion, that the weight of the poem greatly surpasses its length/word usage. Still, the words “another” and “anymore” seem a bit repetitive, so if the lines were rearranged, and the word anymore eliminated, in addition to an elipses to add a suspensive, heavy pause, the poem would be wonderful. Goli I like this poem. Is it more like a senryu than a haiku? I do not see any images than a single man who looks distressed because he has lost a relationship. The poem expresses loneliness very well. Amy another day . . . Alone; |
on the third branch singing singing singing singing on the third branch I just like the imagery that goes with this one. I do kind of like how it gets so particular as to the location of the insect. Also, I like the use of the word "sings" because you usually don't think of the noise insects make as singing, but it puts a nice twist to it. Nate |
I hoped for new grass no new grass
|
vacant men’s room spacious interior I enjoyed this one. I know when I am lugging a bag full of books, I always use the handicapped stall. It seems to be a bit devious due to the fact that you would get a ticket for using the handicapped parking spaces. Kristen |
the light of dawn new wings |
underneath the world underneath the busy world beneath the kitchen |
|
kindergarten open house: crayon leaf prints |
his old work shirt As for the new scarecrow renditions of my haiku, I liked each one very much. However, the one that stood out the most to me is: autumn afternoon I like the word “modeling.” It makes it seem like the scarecrow is proud -- this work shirt symbolizes something of importance. I was trying to convey that with the word “display” but this is very nice. —Carrie Seymour the scarecrow The images of the "old workshirt" and "the scarecrow" in this haiku are very concrete. I enjoy being able to visualize those two images. In class we talked about how "hung up for display" may not be the best second line for this haiku, so here are two edits: his old work shirt his old work— the scarecrow’s autumn afternoon This one makes me think of a retired worker. He has worked his entire life and knows the value of a dollar. Under other circumstances, he would never waste a good shirt. However, today he has given in to the pleas of his grandchildren. His good old work shirt now hangs on their scarecrow. Kristen |
© 2006, Randy Brooks Millikin University
All rights returned to authors upon publication.